I find that hiking offers not only relaxation and a chance to immerse yourself in nature but also an exciting way to embark on a culinary adventure. Every trail reveals stunning landscapes, and every stop along the way holds delectable food treasures. Today, I’ll take you on a journey through two of New York State’s most beautiful hiking routes—Montauk’s Oyster Pond Trail and the Eternal Flame Falls Trail. Together, we’ll explore not just the breathtaking scenery but also the culinary delights waiting to be discovered nearby.
Montauk: Romance of Hiking and Seafood Feasts
Montauk, at the easternmost tip of Long Island, is renowned for its dramatic coastline and fresh seafood. After hiking the Oyster Pond Trail, with the salty breeze still in the air, I found myself diving into the vibrant local food scene for a truly indulgent experience.
1. Montauk Lobster Roll Company
On my first visit to Montauk, I was instantly charmed by this iconic eatery’s famous lobster roll. Each roll is stuffed with generous chunks of fresh lobster meat, lightly seasoned and nestled in a perfectly toasted bun. With just a splash of lemon juice and a hint of butter, every bite was a burst of flavor. Paired with their creamy clam chowder, this meal was the perfect way to refuel after a hike.
The restaurant’s relaxed atmosphere, adorned with coastal decor, adds to the charm. Sitting at the outdoor tables with the sea breeze on my face and the waves in the distance made this meal more than just food—it became a cherished memory of Montauk.
2. The Lobster Grill
After exploring Oyster Pond Trail’s wetlands and forests, I chose this seafood haven to unwind. The Lobster Grill is famed for its seafood platters and spectacular ocean views. Their seafood platter, brimming with lobster, crab legs, shrimp, and oysters, was a symphony of freshness and flavor.
I particularly loved the grilled lobster tail, served with a garlic butter sauce that melted in my mouth. The wine list, featuring local Long Island whites, paired beautifully with the seafood. Dining on their outdoor terrace while watching the sun dip below the horizon was an unforgettable experience.
3. Duryea’s Lobster Deck
Perched right by the water, Duryea’s is a must-visit for its premium seafood and stunning vistas. After a day on the trails, this restaurant became my sanctuary. With open-air seating overlooking the sparkling sea, it offered the perfect setting for a seafood feast.
Their lobster pasta was a standout, with succulent lobster pieces tossed in a flavorful sauce. I also indulged in the seafood tower, a tiered platter of oysters, crab, and shrimp—a great choice for sharing. The combination of exquisite food, mesmerizing views, and a laid-back vibe made this dining experience truly memorable.
Eternal Flame Falls: A Blend of Natural Wonder and Rustic Flavors
Unlike Montauk’s coastal feasts, the culinary scene near Eternal Flame Falls exudes a more rustic charm, showcasing the unique flavors of upstate New York. After marveling at the fascinating flame burning behind the waterfall, I discovered several hidden gems that offered a taste of the region’s warmth and hospitality.
1. The Heights Restaurant & Lounge
Known for its authentic New York State dishes and cozy atmosphere, this restaurant was the perfect place to relax after a hike. Their menu features classic American fare like grilled steak, fried chicken, and homemade pasta, but my favorite was their signature “Flame Burger.” Juicy beef patty topped with house-made spicy sauce made every bite a flavorful delight.
The warm and retro interior added to the comfort, and the window-side tables offered views of the charming town below. Dining here felt like a homecoming, especially after an adventurous day outdoors.
2. Taughannock Falls Overlook Café
If you love dining with a view, this café is a must-visit. Situated near Taughannock Falls, it offers a front-row seat to one of the tallest waterfalls in New York while serving delicious local dishes.
I tried their maple-glazed salmon, perfectly cooked with a delicate sweetness that complemented the fish’s natural flavors. For dessert, their cheesecake was an absolute treat—rich, creamy, and just sweet enough. The friendly staff made great recommendations, enhancing my appreciation of the local food culture.
3. Local Farmers’ Markets
As a traveler, I always enjoy visiting local farmers’ markets, and the ones near Eternal Flame Falls were no exception. These markets exude a pastoral charm and offer fresh local produce, artisanal cheeses, honey, and organic vegetables.
I picked up some ingredients and cooked a simple yet delicious meal at my lodging—pairing it with a bottle of local wine. This experience of creating and savoring a farm-to-table meal added a unique and personal touch to my trip.
Beyond just food, the markets provided an opportunity to connect with local farmers and learn about their sustainable practices. This direct connection to the land and its produce deepened my appreciation for the region’s rich culinary heritage.
A Journey of Senses
Whether it’s Montauk’s lobster rolls and coastal views or Eternal Flame Falls’ rustic flavors and natural wonders, New York State’s hiking and dining experiences are a perfect duo. They offer not only a feast for the eyes but also a celebration of the palate.
Every trail brings its own unique culinary culture waiting to be explored. If you’re a nature lover and a foodie, pack your hiking boots and your appetite, and join me in discovering the beauty and flavors of New York State. Trust me—this is a journey you’ll remember for a lifetime!
